Nice job! Very accurate. My theory: he couldn't look like this in the movie because everyone would start shipping Hayniss (heh, sounds like heinous) instead of Peeniss and Katale. God, this fandom has the best shipper names...
When he first appeared at the Reaping in the first book, all I could think of was this guy named Frank who lives in my hometown lol. His characterization is Frank made over (being the crazy town drunk) lol.
Anyway, this is awesome. Haymitch is one of my favorite characters behind Katniss, Rue, and Cinna.
Love Haymitch! He looks gorgeous in both of these picture (and I like your version a lot better than how they're portraying him in the movies-- I didn't see him as a blond when reading). Anyways, love this!